Maryland Newsline
Home Page

Politics

Business & Tech

Schools

Crime & Justice

Health

Et Cetera

Related Link:

Political Ethics Special Report Home
Ethics Quiz: What Would You Do?

By Amy Silva
Maryland Newsline staff
Friday, May 11, 2001


Question:

You are a Maryland senator who sits on the Health and Human Services subcommittee of the Budget and Taxation Committee. A Maryland medical lobbying group has offered to pay your way to come speak at a weekend conference it will be sponsoring. The group will pay for your travel, hotel, food and entertainment at the conference. While it won't be rolling out the red carpet for you, it will end up spending quite a bit more than $500 for you to attend. You are to speak about medical reform in the Maryland Legislature and are free to say what you want. What do you do?

answer a
Agree to go and speak at the conference. The accommodations are reasonable, and you will be speaking free of influence. Even though the group does have a financial interest in legislation that would pass through the subcommittee you sit on, you will stay impartial.

answer b
Agree to go and speak at the conference only after you have notified the Joint Ethics Committee. Since the cost of the gift would exceed $500, you feel it is important to clear this one with the ethics authorities. But since this is a business conference and you do have to speak, you feel that it is reasonable that you be allowed to accept the invitation.

answer c
Decline the offer to go and speak. Even though it will be a business trip, you think that the control your subcommittee has over legislation affecting this group is enough that some people might later criticize you for being partial to them, even though you believe in your heart you can remain impartial.

Copyright © 2001 University of Maryland College of Journalism


Top of Page | Home Page