Politics

Business & Tech

Schools

Crime & Justice

Health

Et Cetera

Special Report
Main Page
Challengers in Crowded Senate Field Say GOP Has Become a Party of One

Challengers Bring  Unsuccessful Campaign Histories

By Hazel Feigenblatt
Capital News Service
Wednesday, Feb. 25, 2004

WASHINGTON - If the 11 candidates who are trying to unseat Democratic Sen. Barbara Mikulski fail, it won't be from lack of practice.

Between them, the nine Republicans and two Democrats have run for office at least 22 times, and won elected office only once.

The only officeholder is state Sen. E.J. Pipkin, who spent more than $500,000 of his own money to win a State House seat in 2002 in his first bid for office.

The Queen Anne's County Republican is seen as the strongest of the Mikulski challengers, reporting a campaign budget of $376,766 as of December -- $250,000 of which is his own money -- that is going toward radio and TV ads to make his name known. His main issues are more jobs and cleaning up the Chesapeake Bay.

Corrogan Vaughn, a Baltimore County limousine company owner, has been knocking on doors with a message of bringing jobs back to Maryland, improving the health care system and the schools. The Center for Responsive Politics says Vaughn has raised $3,652, but he said he is not worried about money.

"At the end of the day, (the election) it's about the people. Money would come," said Vaughn, a Republican who ran an unsuccessful write-in campaign for Senate in 2002.

John Stafford has been running since 1998: once for the state House of Delegates and two times for the U.S. Senate. The Anne Arundel County Republican said he wants to unseat Mikulski because of her pro-choice abortion stance, and his campaign -- "Bye-Bye Barb" -- has been conducted mainly through the Internet.

Gene Zarwell is another Republican using the Internet for his campaign, as well as visiting political events, a campaign strategy that he said should cost him nothing. The Gambrills businessman and pilot has run twice for comptroller, once for the House and twice before for Senate. Zarwell's main goal is to build up private business, because he thinks the state discourages for-profit activities.

He thinks Mikulski is "as vulnerable as can be . . . I have no idea why they keep voting for her."

Ray Bly, a Jessup appliance-store owner and Vietnam veteran, ran unsuccessfully for Howard County Council in 2002. The GOP hopeful said he has distributed about 1,000 bumper stickers and rallied in shopping centers in several counties in his Senate bid, which calls for less-aggressive foreign policy, tighter controls on illegal immigration and protection of veteran benefits.

"All is cut, cut, cut," Bly said of the current administration. "Do we have to buy our own equipment to go to war?"

James A. Kodak, a prostate cancer researcher, said he knows he is a "long shot" because he has not run for office before, but the Odenton Republican ran to start building name recognition. His proposals are cheaper prescription drugs, limited legal fees and development of a light freight transportation system.

Other Republicans are Dorothy Corry Jennings of Baltimore City, who ran for Congress in 1998; Eileen "Cookie Baker" Martin, a Crofton housewife; and Earl S. Gordon of Olney.

Democrats in the race have almost as much campaign experience as the Republicans: Robert Kaufman has run for Baltimore mayor twice, for House twice and for Senate twice, while Sid Altman has run twice for the House, once for the U.S. Senate and once for the state Senate.

Kaufman, a Baltimore Socialist activist, said his purpose is not to win but to bring up issues that otherwise would not be discussed. He calls for fighting terrorism with a foreign policy that does not terrorize the world, and spending on schools and health rather than on benefits for big businesses.

Altman, who has spent less than $1,000 on this election, said he was encouraged by the 31,502 votes he received in a 2000 bid for U.S. Senate. The retired teacher from Gaithersburg is campaigning on a platform of more rights for renters, differentiated education for people with learning problems and cuts in military spending.

By Hazel Feigenblatt
Capital News Service
Wednesday, Feb. 25, 2004

WASHINGTON - There are nine candidates running in the Maryland Republican primary for U.S. Senate, but as far as the state Republican Party is concerned, there may as well only be one.

"There's only one candidate that has a decent chance, and that's (state Sen. E.J.) Pipkin," said Eric Sutton, executive director of the Maryland Republican Party. "He's right on the issues."

Sutton was careful to point out that the party has not officially endorsed any candidate in the race. But some of the other eight do not see it that way.

"There is a blatant bias towards one candidate, where there are nine running," said Corrogan R. Vaughn, a Baltimore limousine company owner who was a write-in candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2000.

"There's no question that the party should be completely neutral until the primary, and I don't think that's been the case," said James A. Kodak, a cancer researcher who is in his first election.

Several of the GOP outsiders noted that Pipkin's campaign manager, Steve Crim, worked for the state party until he quit to work on the campaign. They also said the party has failed to return their calls, and that it has been impossible for them to set up meetings with party leaders.

But Sutton denied playing favorites. He said he has offered help to those who have asked, but none have called the party's office, except for Vaughn.

Sutton said the party does not even have the phone numbers of most of the eight, and does not know who they are. Any party member can register as candidate.

Crim insisted that the Pipkin campaign has not received any special treatment from the party.

"We haven't had any endorsement, but we're not focused on what everybody else is doing. We have our own game plan," he said.

So far, that plan has been to get Pipkin's name out to voters. The Queen Anne's County Republican has never run a statewide race and is little known outside his Eastern Shore district, where he spent more than $500,000 of his own money in 2002 -- his first bid for office -- to unseat a popular Democratic incumbent.

Pipkin, a Dundalk native who made a fortune as a Wall Street financier, has repeated that pattern so far in his U.S. Senate campaign, contributing $250,000 of his own money to a campaign bank account that totaled $376,766 as of Dec. 31, according to the Federal Election Commission.

An October poll by Gonzales Research and Marketing Strategies said 36 percent of likely voters recognized Pipkin's name -- but the same poll said Mikulski would beat him by a 57-26 percent margin.

By contrast, few of the other eight Republicans have raised the minimum $5,000 needed to file a report with the FEC, and pollsters do not include their names in surveys. And they say that has swayed the party to back Pipkin.

"He (Pipkin) is the pick. Period," said Senate candidate Ray Bly, an appliance store owner who ran unsuccessfully in 2002 for Howard County Council.

Vaughn said the party "sabotaged" his campaign, waiting months before it gave him access to the voters list, refusing to post information about his candidacy on the party Web site and denying his requests for meetings with party Chairman John Kane or Gov. Robert L. Ehrlich.

Sutton said Vaughn is not a serious candidate, but that he was offered the same information as Pipkin.

Vaughn said that offer came just weeks before the primary -- and only after he sent a letter to Kane complaining about his treatment. He said he ultimately declined the offer to help his campaign with Internet services and press releases, because "no candidate should be given special treatment."

Kodak said he has tried to contact both Kane and Ehrlich, but has received no answer so far. Stafford said he even offered to make a contribution to the party, but nobody answered his calls either.

Sutton said no candidates have called his office.

But however bruising the primary, analysts say the party's nominee can expect an even tougher fight in November: Mikulski has 17 years in the Senate, a string of victories in the heavily Democratic state and $2.1 million cash on hand by the end of 2003.

"She (Mikulski) will be re-elected pretty easily because this is a Democratic state . . . and she is popular," said Michael Korzi, a professor at Towson University.

The fact that most of the Republicans have little money, campaign structure, name recognition or public office experience -- not to mention 11 lost elections between five of them -- "does nothing but help her (Mikulski)," said Melissa Deckman, assistant professor at Washington College.

Copyright © 2004 University of Maryland Philip Merrill College of Journalism


Top of Page | Home Page